Sp - A Promise Best Left Unkept Walkthrough With

"A Promise Best Left Unkept" is a side quest in the video game "The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt," which involves Geralt of Rivia dealing with the aftermath of a rather complicated situation involving a sorceress named Laroche and the Nilfgaardian Empire. This walkthrough will guide you through completing the quest, including some specifics on handling situations with signs (Sp) which likely refers to using Signs (magic abilities) effectively during combat or interactions.

How to Earn SP:

  • Exploration: Interacting with specific environment objects (old letters, photographs, the pocket watch).
  • Dialogue Branches: Choosing responses that acknowledge the promise rather than avoid it.
  • Side Quests: Helping NPCs who knew the deceased friend, Clara.
  • Hidden Triggers: Being at the right place at the right time (detailed below).

6. Tips for True/Secret Endings (if any)

  • A Promise Best Left Unkept doesn’t have a “harem” or “golden” ending — it’s meant to be a dramatic choice between loyalty and desire.
  • The “Promise Left Unkept” title is ironic — the game forces you to either keep it (Ayane) or break it (Yuna).
  • Some players consider Yuna’s route the “true” route because the title suggests breaking the promise, but that’s subjective.

4. Route Splitting

Ending C: The True Ending (Unkept No More)

This is the canonical "best" outcome where the promise is fulfilled or recontextualized. a promise best left unkept walkthrough with sp

  • Prerequisites:
    1. Maximized SP (Chapters 1-3 "Work/Serious" route).
    2. Successful Crisis Check (Chapter 4).
    3. Successful Confrontation Check (Chapter 5).
  • The Final Choice (Chapter 6):
    • Choice: "Keep the promise at all costs."
    • Mechanic: This option consumes all remaining SP.
    • Walkthrough: If you have the option available, select it. If it is greyed out, you missed a point in Chapter 1 or 3.
  • Narrative: The protagonist utilizes all their development and connections to overcome the final obstacle, resulting in the full closure of the narrative arc.

Part 1: Understanding SP (Story Points) – The Currency of Commitment

In A Promise Best Left Unkept, SP is not just experience—it is a measure of how concretely Elias clings to his vow. Each SP earned represents a memory, a detail, or an emotional anchor. "A Promise Best Left Unkept" is a side

Key locations

  1. Rowan’s Family Home — starting point, personal items, first clue.
  2. Willow Lane Church Ruins — ritual site, hidden passage.
  3. Hollow Pond — site of the original promise, environmental puzzle.
  4. Town Archives / Library — research, NPC notes, optional lore.
  5. The Old Farmhouse — final confrontation, choice point.

A Promise Best Left Unkept: Walkthrough & Ending Guide

Walkthrough — "A Promise Best Left Unkept" (with SP)